Home

Financial Statement…in the bin.

Leave a comment

Straight to the bin.

My last stint as a PCCI Director was in 2014-2016, but I didn’t get re-elected in 2016. Those who follow this blog know the details of what happened. I still drop by the office once in a while for a few official business errands. I do accept local judging assignments and might bump into a few Directors who are also judges during the same show. That’s basically it, having chosen to move on.

https://withinzones2to8.wordpress.com/2016/02/22/life-goes-on/

But today I received the clubs 2017 financial statement…and got reminded of things. External/Independent Auditors will provide a Confidential Auditors Report that will report on all the financial leaks that they find in their audit. I asked a copy of it during the 2015 General Assembly, I asked a copy of this Confidential Auditors Report, well, I never got it.

I wasn’t in the mood to research a full feature for this post. I do know that the accuracy of an External Auditors Financial Audit to begin with, is critically dependent on the honesty and accuracy of what is submitted to the auditors. I attached two links that should explain why the report made it to the bin…well at least it’s in the recyclable bin.

http://fortune.com/2015/10/19/auditors-financial-reports/

http://www.understand-accounting.net/TheReliabilityandAccuracyoffinancialstatements.html

The new Judges Competency Framework of the Kennel Club

Leave a comment

http://www.fci.be/en/Show-Judges-44.html

https://www.thekennelclub.org.uk/training/judges-education/breed-show-judges-training/judges-competency-framework

I follow the twitter account of Dog World, and on the 26th of April they tweeted about the new Judges Competency Framework. Reactions to this new “Framework” are mixed. I’ve read it twice and continue to go back and forth. I’ve also read commentaries and comments about this framework.

What can I pick up based on my research? It seems to be agreed upon by all that the old system needed to be changed. The most common reason being a lack of transparency with second being competency issues. It seems that the old system had transparency issues when it came to the procedure and process of acquiring a license, from initial breed all the way to all breed. The next issue of transparency seems to have something to do with judging assignments, the requirements and the judge selection and approval for an assignment. Finally we have the issue of competency.

Looking at the new framework, it quickly reminded me of an ISO Process and Procedural Manual. The framework will address issues of transparency which pleased a lot of people. However, I personally believe that transparency is a political/policy issue, meaning any policy to curb it’s lack, really depends on the admins effort to implement transparency policies. Having said that, the framework explains to every aspiring and existing judge where he or she is exactly, what he/she is exactly entitled to and the requirements for the next step. The framework covers procedure, requirements and performance measurements, matters that are addressed by ISO. If I were an aspiring judge, this framework is something I would appreciate.

The Kennel Club is also introducing the “The Kennel Club Academy,” an online education platform that can be accessed 24/7. A mandatory continuing education is to be attended every five years for existing whatever level you are in. Aside from the usual breed seminars, a mentoring program is now in place. The online education is the one that has had the most response in social media. There are mixed reactions, from it’s cost to it’s efficacy. Can online education replace actual live practicums?

The Devil is in the detail. My interest is how did the whole thing come about. Did they have Focus Group Discussions? Did they consult all stake holders? Did they ask help? The intention of the Framework is good but I see too many moving parts. I’m biased towards the FCI guidelines because it is simple albeit lacking in education curriculum which I believe the present Show Judges Commission is addressing under the Chairmanship of John Wauben. The Framework also seems to lack a timeline goal for a diligent, studious aspiring judge with a plan to become an all rounder which the FCI Guidelines has. I don’t have much to say on curriculum that will address competence until I’ve seen the online education platform but this effort shows that the Kennel Club is ahead of FCI in this matter. The bottom line is, if this Framework will make better Kennel Club Judges then we all wish them good luck.

%d bloggers like this: